
Usability Evaluation
Students can’t find their own degree on uoZone
Six everyday tasks, five first-year students, and what happened when they got lost on the University of Ottawa’s student portal.
5
Participants
6
tasks
18
trends identified
9
issues identified across 5 themes
16
recommendations to improve UX
Overview
Role
UX Researcher
Method
Remote moderated usability test
Participants
5 students
Team
5 researchers
Tool
Loop11
Tested Device
Desktop
Session
30–45 minutes
Timeline
February 2026
Context
uoZone is the University of Ottawa’s student portal: enrolment, transcripts, exam schedules, volunteer placements. Its users include undergraduate, graduate, PhD and external students.
What they need is simple: find the right information quickly and accurately, or learn that it isn’t there.
The Problem
🚨 Students struggle to efficiently find academic information such as degree requirements and exam schedules on uoZone.
🔍 Research question: where exactly does finding things break down, and why?
What getting lost looks like
One participant’s real click path while trying to request a co-curricular record (Task 6). They left uoZone for Google, found a guide, came back, reached the right page, and still couldn’t work out how to request the report.
Applications
›
What-if reports
›
Applications
›
Work study nav.
›
Applications
›
Home
›
Google search
›
Get your CCR guide
›
Applications
›
CEN
›
CCR
›
Home
›
Back
›
Back
›
Back
›
…
💬 “I feel lost. I have no idea how to request the report. Really difficult to do. I feel uncomfortable performing this task.”
How we tested it
1. Scope and task design
We turned our objectives into six task scenarios that reflect common student goals, covering both navigation and comprehension.
2. Sessions
Remote, moderated sessions with think-aloud and neutral facilitation. We used one script for every session so tasks stayed comparable, and closed with a short debrief.
3. Measurement
ISO-aligned measures: task outcome (success, success with hint, fail), time on task, and satisfaction from reactions, comments and a System Usability Scale questionnaire. We logged every error and prioritised issues by severity.
🎯 Choosing the right people
A screener questionnaire recruited current uOttawa students with low to moderate uoZone familiarity, mostly in their first year.
We deliberately excluded very familiar users and anyone with a very positive attitude toward uoZone. Experts work around design flaws, and fans forgive them. We wanted the people who would hit the problems.
All participants consented to screen and audio recording.
The six tasks
Task 1
View degree progress and remaining courses
All 5 left the expected path
Task 2
Find your unofficial transcript
5/5 succeeded, all said too many steps
Task 3
Find where to change your preferred name
4/5 found it difficult
Task 4
View this semester’s exam schedule
2/5 unsure what the page told them
Task 5
Register for volunteer work
100% abandoned
Task 6
Request your co-curricular record (CCR)
1/5 completed
What we found
Across 30 task attempts, three patterns explained most of the trouble. Overall, 18 trends identified.
0/5
noticed 'My Academic Requirements' shortcut
The thing students needed was on the page, and nobody saw it
In Task 1, none of the five participants noticed the 'My Academic Requirements' shortcut. Four went through Applications, then Enroll, because they think of degree progress as part of course enrolment. All five left the expected path at least once, and three turned to the general program website instead.

100%
abandoned volunteer registration
When browsing fails, students leave
Nobody completed volunteer registration in Task 5: four of five rated it extremely difficult and two switched to Google. In Task 6, 40% of participants went through 13 or more pages before finding the CCR page, and one reached 17.
Every participant’s first click was Applications, so students know where to look.
The page itself fails them: an overcrowded list, an “Other” bucket, and a Co-Curricular Record behind an abbreviation.
💬 “I need to look through a thousand buttons on the application again and again.”
💬 “I probably just go Google.”
5/5
said that the transcript took more steps than expected
Even success felt uncertain
Everyone found the unofficial transcript, yet all five said it took more steps than expected, and many hesitated after clicking “View Report” because the page gave little sign that anything was happening.
In Task 4, the two students with no exams saw only “An exam schedule is not available for this term” and couldn’t tell whether the page was broken or empty.
Labels added to the confusion: in Task 3, only one of five strongly agreed that menu names were clear.

Recommendations
Nine issues in five themes, ranked by severity. Each came with a mock-up of the proposed direction.
Navigation and information architecture
1.1
Critical
Degree progress is hard to locate
Add a clickable progress indicator to the uoZone homepage, showing overall and per-category progress visually, as a percentage, and as credits completed against needed.
1.2
Major
Students link degree progress only to course enrolment
Meet their mental model: show remaining and completed courses early inside the enrolment flow.
1.3
Major
The 'Applications' page is overcrowded
Show grouped applications by default and break the “Other” bucket into logical groups.
Findability and discoverability
2.1
Critical
The Co-Curricular Record is buried
Create a “Career, Experiential Learning & Volunteering” category in 'Applications' page with a clear primary path that doesn’t depend on external guides.
2.2
Critical
“Request Official CCR” button can’t be found
Move action buttons out of the left-side 'Options' menu and place them directly under the CCR tab header.
Labelling and terminology
3.1
Major
Abbreviations reduce clarity
Spell it out: “Co-curricular Record (CCR).”
3.2
Major
“Advisement Report” means little to students
Rename it in student language, such as “View My Academic Requirements Report.”
Visual hierarchy and efficiency
4
Major
Accordions increase interaction cost when reviewing degree requirements
Auto-expand incomplete sections and visually distinguish complete versus incomplete categories with colour, icons and banners.
Feedback and system status
5
Major
An empty exam page for system feedback is unclear when no exams are scheduled. It reads like an error.
Replace the message with a clear status-oriented statement: “You currently have no exams scheduled for this term.”
Project Retrospective
The core problem is not that uoZone lacks features. Students can’t find them. Information architecture, ambiguous labels, weak visual signals and non-actionable messages all push the same way, until students give up and use Google instead.
Our recommendations aim to lower cognitive load, cut task errors and raise satisfaction.
💡 What I learned
Success rates hide friction: All five participants completed the transcript task, yet all five said it took too many steps. Pairing task outcomes with perceived effort caught a problem that completion alone would have missed.
Leaving the product is a finding. Participants turned to Google in Tasks 1, 5 and 6. When people abandon the system’s own navigation, that is a clear sign the information architecture failed.
Recruiting shapes what you can see. Excluding very familiar and very positive users meant the sessions showed real friction rather than workarounds.
⚠️ Limits worth naming
Five participants is enough to surface recurring problems, not to produce reliable percentages, so I read the figures above as signals.
We tested desktop only, and with mostly first-year students by design.
➡️ Next Step:
The natural next step is to prototype the homepage progress indicator and the regrouped Applications page, then rerun the same six tasks and compare.
The expected impact (lower cognitive load, fewer task errors, higher satisfaction) is not yet measured.

